This is the only product I have ever found that actually makes my hands, feet, knees, etc. look, feel, and actually be soft and hydrated. However, I must agree that this current "lot" or "formula run" does PILL and come off. I've had to literally stand in the shower and slough it all off so it wouldn't end up all over my sheets. If it can be like the earlier formula, I will continue to buy this, by the boat load, forever!!!! 10 Stars!!